Stories and Poems from the Writers' Critique Group of First Reformed Church, Schenectady, New York

Category: Satire

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer Deconstructed

By Rudy Petersen.

Sure, you’ve heard the song dozens—if not hundreds—of times.

Let’s revisit the lyrics once more and then address some ethical questions.

You know Dasher and Dancer
And Prancer and Vixen,
Comet and Cupid
And Donner and Blitzen.
But do you recall
The most famous reindeer of all?

Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer
Had a very shiny nose
And if you ever saw it
You would even say it glows.

All of the other reindeer
Used to laugh and call him names
They never let poor Rudolph
Join in any reindeer games.

Then one foggy Christmas Eve
Santa came to say
Rudolph with your nose so bright
Won’t you guide my sleigh tonight?
Then all the reindeer loved him
And they shouted out with glee
“Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer
You’ll go down in history.”

OK, there it is, the whole tacky story in 113 simple English words. You, perhaps, may have seen the movie, which seeks to offer a back-story to the song. Now I must ask: have you ever really considered what is going on here—socially, ethically—regarding common decency toward other individuals? If not, then I suggest the key questions before us are these:

Item: Are the other reindeer immature and/or naive?                                   Hint: instead of getting ready for work on Christmas Eve, they’re playing games.

Item: Are the other reindeer a gang of bullies?
Hint: They habitually have been laughing at Rudolph and calling him names. 

Item: Are the other reindeer hypocrites?
Hint: When Rudolph’s “nose so bright” leads the way, thereby saving the jobs of the entire team, then they all “loved” him. Hmm.

Item: What is the nature of love in this song?                                                   Hint: Does the love seem superficial, tied only to a hope of sharing the glory—in effect, sucking up to Rudolph to get to Santa himself?

Item: What is Santa’s proper role in this situation?
Hint: He’s the boss, the head honcho, the leader. Does he not have a responsibility to use this episode as a teaching moment?

Item: Have the other reindeer reached an epiphany, or will they revert to their former behavior?
Hint: We hear the song, and probably see the movie every Christmas season, and yet the story never changes. Why not?

I have considered traveling to the North Pole and confronting the reindeer gang to press them on these points, but I suspect they would give me little or no satisfaction. I might interview Santa, and possibly Mrs. Claus, but I anticipate getting nothing but jolly elf-twaddle about it all being in “fun”—you know, the sweetness and light approach—always a good dodge.

So, I’ll leave this matter to you to ponder. Why do so many citizens greet the annual holiday with fond recollection of this most suspect of popular tunes? Is it tradition? Is it raw sentimentality? Bah humbug! I say.

I realize that these are not issues that you, or even us working together, can resolve. But I thank you for staying with me on this important cultural issue. I feel so much better now.

A Christmas Letter     

By Joyce Beland.

Dear Friends and Family,

Well, it’s time for our annual Christmas missive. This year we baked 15 different cookies. Five are gluten free. Three are vegan. We also made three fruitcakes. One soaked in rum. One soaked in bourbon. And another soaked in rye. Not letting a single drop go to waste, we drank anything leftover. We also purchased six live trees. Two Fraser Firs. Two Douglas Firs. And two Scotch Pines. We decorated our “little forest” with new homemade ornaments and family heirlooms. We stationed the trees throughout our home. Once Christmas is over, we’ll plant them on our property. Also, we purchased many meaningful gifts and wrapped them with love. We shipped out some and placed others under one of our trees. Glad we decided to keep things simple this year and skip the usual craziness.  Now we have time to write Christmas cards to our 1,000 closest friends. Of course, we could use social media. But an old-fashioned hand-written note is more personal. “Happy holidays” if you want to be politically correct. “Merry Christmas” if you’re right-wing, government-fearing Christians. We’ve been keeping a close eye on this war against Christmas. All the folks on Facebook are posting about it. We hated to do it, but we gave up our Starbuck’s coffee. The nerve of them, using a red “holiday” cup. Where was baby Jesus or Santa Claus? A bunch of left-wing, liberal socialists must run the company. The spouse and I discussed getting a divorce this year. We decided not to go through with it. Too many years invested in each other. We worked things out, pretty much, and don’t talk to each other unless we must. Thing is, we’re both getting deaf and wind up shouting at each other. Still sounds like we’re fussing and fighting. Our oldest boy was back in rehab this year. He’s been in for alcoholism, drug addiction, and sex addiction. This time it was for his gambling problem. Who knew putting scratch-off tickets in his stocking would lead to that? Our daughter blessed us with another grandchild. She isn’t sure who the father is. We suspect she knows but doesn’t want to say. Not that we care. We’re already raising her other three. We don’t know who their daddies are either. We’ve welcomed the new baby girl. We’re thrilled to support her mother. She should have her Ph.D. in Ancient Babylonian Philosophy sometime next year. It’s an honor to be the parents of a child with multiple college degrees. This will be her fourth doctorate. Our youngest son is also doing quite well. He’s been keeping a low profile since that embezzling incident. Thank goodness we found a competent lawyer to represent him. It was well worth taking out another mortgage on our house. Anything for our children. We also decided to sell the vacation home. It was getting too expensive to maintain. And since the kids have grown up, we weren’t using it as much. Our youngest promised that once he comes out of hiding, he’ll buy us a bigger and better place. We’re hoping for some place tropical with servants. We continue to enjoy our retirement and feel blessed to be living in this great country. We’re overjoyed to exercise our second amendment rights. For Christmas we’re giving each other the gift of adding to our private arsenal. You can never bear too many arms. And no one has the right to take those guns from us. The NRA will be getting a little something extra from us this year, for their important work. We’re grateful too for our good health. As we get older some things don’t work like they once did. We may have to replace certain parts. We’re like old cars. We’re grateful for our family. We mentioned our kids and grandkids. We also want to brag about our parents. We’re blessed to still have them with us. My mom and dad live in our attic. They love the beautiful view from up there. My in-laws have the run of our basement. It’s another blessing to have them do our laundry. We enjoy when both sets of parents visit the main part of the house. But we can’t entertain them at the same time. Since that mishap at our wedding reception, they still despise each other. It was a tiny fire and flood. Our guests only spent a few hours at the hospital. Most were in and out of the emergency room. The insurance paid for most of the damage. You would think they would forgive and forget after all these years. The fact they can recall every detail shows they still have their wits about them. There is nothing wrong with their minds. We’re happy they’re mentally fit and enjoy seeing them once a month. We’re honored you’re our true American friends and privileged you’re a part of our family.  Each one born on this great USA soil, as far back as we remember. God bless America!